Thanks a lot for the replies. I will definitely take all the advice you have provided but to close out this thread, I just want to make sure I understand the steps and my approach to treat the Ich so I can move my general questions to a more appropriate topic group.

1. For the Ich treatment - should I use another treatment or continue to use the Ich-Atackr?

2. As I have read and as the group has pointed out the stress brings on the Ich. So for treatment should I continue to keep them together or go ahead and split all 3 up and treat individually, or would this introduce more stress at this point.

3. As Ben suggested: "I'd pick up an established piece of live rock at one of our sponsors stores and let it ride! Maybe around 10 pounds" should I place the live rock during or post-Ich treatment?

Thanks for all your help guys. I'm sure you will be hearing from me again soon in other topics. It's a steep learning curve and it's been so long since i had my FO tank in college but I know the reward and beauty with all the hard work is worth it to share this hobby with my family. Can't wait to start getting back into the hobby and into "reef madness" but as Louis suggested going to take this thing slow to avoid these problems moving forward and learn from all of you.

Thanks again,
Mark