Its a crying shame that you are relying on the post to just go away. You should be able to have a discussion even a disagreement, and it should be able to stay posted for everyone to see and make up there own mind about each side. As far as right or wrong....I am right. I accidentally posted the wrong name and admitted to that....however, cleaner shrimp will help cure the problem. I am not the only one to stumble upon this great mystery. wink wink. As I stated before, go read the article I sited in the new volume of the Coral Magazine. I guess Joe Yaiullo is wrong too. Maybe you should contact him and let him know.