I'm also debating it. I have always been the guy who flew to the destination then spent a week there, which I love. But I think this will give me a taste of a lot of carribean stops in a short amount of time. So far my experience Aruba has had the best beaches. We had the most fun at the grand cayman since there was just sooo much to do. We literally had two excursions booked almost everyday. I have also been to Belize but I would recommend cayman over that. If I could find one going to st marteen I think I would try it since the wife wants to go so bad.