Simply put: there is no cheaper version of the Vortech. I was a non-believer as well -- until I got my first pump. If you're not familiar with the Vortech product line, read up on them... they're not just pumps... they're wave generation devices, with infinite adjustability on speed, pulse length, randomness, etc. There is not a product on the market that compares to them. You can do just fine going with the cheaper solution, don't get me wrong -- but it will take more pumps and more invasion in the tank to get what you want. If you have to add, say, 3 pumps to your tank -- you're already halfway to the purchase cost of an MP10.
Look up the product line, and some videos of what they can do -- you'll be impressed
Edit: as a clarification to my initial statement -- the other propeller pumps on the market do a great job of providing non-laminar flow, but there is not a single one that can achieve what the Vortech line can, with as little power draw as it can. The aesthetics of the pumps is much nicer for a show-type display, but their abilities and range is FAR more than this alone.
-Justin
Last edited by corruption; Wed, 13th Jan 2010 at 11:11 AM.
http://binarybuccaneers.org/ninja_small2.jpgBeware the wheelchair ninja...http://binarybuccaneers.org/ninja_small.jpg
http://binarybuccaneers.org/gabe.jpg
I have an open top tank, won't the waves crash out of the tank!?
Only if you tune it that high -- you're missing a big point here -- infinite adjustability. You can (and people do) run MP10's in 10 gallon aquariums -- they can be adjusted that low.
Also -- wave generation is not the only thing these do... you can run constant flow, you have 2 variable and random modes of operation, and 2 variable pulse modes for wave generation... you can do a LOT with one pump -- you're not stuck with one concept, by any means.
-Justin
http://binarybuccaneers.org/ninja_small2.jpgBeware the wheelchair ninja...http://binarybuccaneers.org/ninja_small.jpg
http://binarybuccaneers.org/gabe.jpg
It was pointed out that there are cheaper options than the Vortech -- but as a final point to this, I'll just say it as simple as I can think of...
Once you have true random current generation in your tank, you'll NEVER want to go back.
-Justin
http://binarybuccaneers.org/ninja_small2.jpgBeware the wheelchair ninja...http://binarybuccaneers.org/ninja_small.jpg
http://binarybuccaneers.org/gabe.jpg
They're price locked anywhere they're advertised -- you won't find the items for less than $195 (MP10), $280 (MP20) or $419 (MP40w) advertised anywhere. There are occasional vendors who will sell them for cheaper than this -- perhaps someone else will chime in with information as it relates to this. I don't know any vendors who will do this, so have no recommendations in that realm
They are worth every penny of the purchase price, even at full MSRP, IMO... Between the Tunze Wavebox, and Vortech pumps -- there's no need for me to ever get extremely invasive with pumps in a tank again
-Justin
http://binarybuccaneers.org/ninja_small2.jpgBeware the wheelchair ninja...http://binarybuccaneers.org/ninja_small.jpg
http://binarybuccaneers.org/gabe.jpg