How old is the original group?
If they are as territorial as freshwater African Cichlids, rearranging the tank or leaving the lights off may help. I would not add a single fish - the more that are added reduces the liklihood of a fish being singled out and killed. Adding juveniles may also reduce the risk of them being seen as a threat.
My Reef System: 215g Brick 72x24x29 Dual Overflows | 4x 250w MH | 4x IceCap 39w T5 w/ Actinics | MSX-250 Skimmer | 1/3hp Chiller | 16w UV | Aquacontroller 3 | Lunar Sim | AquaSurf |Tunze Wavebox | 2x Tunze Stream 6101 | MRC Dual Nano Calcium Reactor | GEO Kalk Reactor | Pan World 150PS Pump | Phosban & Carbon Reactors