Definitely agree that a Naso would not be the right fit for this tank. I am stocking a blonde Naso in my 8' FOWLR.

I have always found the tilefish fascinating. Most materials I've read give them a low aquarium suitability. (Scott Michael only gives them a 2 out of 5 in his book). Richard is your experience with them different? I have great respect for your advice and would be willing to give one a chance if you think its chances of survival are good. I have also heard that tilefish prefer dimmer tanks and I have about 800 watts of lighting, so would that effect your opinion?

What about a neon dottyback? I know they are aggressive, but being the last add to an established tank does anybody have experience with that lowering the aggression. I have added fish in a peaceful to aggressive order on that reasoning and so far so good.

Thanks for the input.