Unfortunately you've run into a spot where many of reefers run into. I've run into this problem personally, and have asked numerous people how to remedy this. I've had frags go from my tank to other local reefers, with various results. Here are a couple of things that you might want to try:
Feeding your tank phyto
increase the current around that particular coral
some reefers have documented greater polyp extension after they have installed a refugium
check to see if the polyps come out when the lights are off
HTH
The person that first ran with scissors ruined it for the rest of us.