Log in

View Full Version : CO2 absorbent - an experiment



klwheat
Sat, 8th Oct 2016, 02:59 PM
Ok, a little background. My pH has always run a bit low - 7.7-7.95 (rarely hitting 8) despite all other parameters in check. I found this a bit frustrating, but didn't want to try to artificially increase it and mess up something else. Well, I figured if these corals should just naturally prefer a pH closer to their norm, so I've been doing a lot of reading.
This seems to be an issue in newer houses that are more tightly sealed up. We had the same problem with our last house and tank. As I continued reading, I realized our house was particularly at risk for this due to occupancy - 2 adults and 2 good-sized kiddos plus 4 big dogs. That's a LOT of CO2. Well, since we such nice, cool weather the other week, I thought I'd try an experiment. Left several windows open as much of the day as I could, and see what happens. Well, I didn't screenshot from my apex, but my pH range moved up to 8-8.2 during the day with only that change. When it warmed up and I was out of the house, windows closed and pH went right back down (usually up or down within a matter of hours).
Ok, well maybe there's something to it!
Now, part 2. I can't leave the windows open all that often (don't care for the heat that much...lol) so what else to do. One of the biggest ways more air gets into the solution of our tanks is our skimmers. If you have high CO2 in the air in the house, it'll naturally be entering the water in higher than "normal" levels. This decreases the pH as CO2 increases. So, I hooked a container of CO2 absorbent (similar to that used in anesthesia or scuba rebreather equipment) to the air intake for my skimmer.
The result, my pH has consistently been 8-8.2 all week since I hooked it up.
Now, the true test...lets see if my corals care over time.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

FarmerTy
Sun, 9th Oct 2016, 08:04 AM
If you want an easy solution without continued media use and replacement, just run your skimmer air intake line outside. Put a small medicine bottle with some activated carbon at the end of it just in case to scrub toxins out of the air and be mindful of placement so bugs can't crawl into it or someone spray like pesticides near it.

I used the CO2 absorbent and at least for me, required replacement every 2-3 weeks.

klwheat
Sun, 9th Oct 2016, 08:54 AM
It looks like it'll be every 2-3 weeks for me as well. Running a skimmer line outside isn't an option for me with the tank placement...I've thought about that as well.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Justin
Sun, 9th Oct 2016, 02:54 PM
In my previous house, I would get a deeper swing in my pH due to CO2 levels in my home. To counteract it, I created my own CO2 scrubber by buying the media from BRS and attached an airline through the bottom of a plastic jug, filling the jug up with the media and keeping the lid open. This helped tremendously and as long as I kept an eye on the material changing color, no CO2 massive swings. Thing worked like a charm and worth looking into for you.

klwheat
Sun, 9th Oct 2016, 03:30 PM
Pretty much what I'm doing...I just got an actual CO2 absorbent container to hook up


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk