New Lights

[Jamie]

I am about to purchase lights for my 150...5X2X2.

I have it narrowed down to two all T5 rigs.

This one... http://www.specialty-lights.com/960093.html Which is a Workhorse set-up claiming that the ballast is properly matched to the bulbs to prolong bulb life. Because I already own a Workhorse ballast...and most of the shipping is free, I can get a 6X80 watt set-up for about $500.

Then this one... http://www.reefgeek.com/lighting/T5_Fluorescent/Sunlight_Supply/Tek_2_Retrofit_Kits/60_inch__6x80W_Tek_2_T5_Very_High-Output_Retrofit_Kit_w!_Bulbs_by_ReefGeek which is a IceCap set-up that claims to "overdrive" the bulbs to 100 watts. This will run me $661 shipped for a 6X100 watt set-up.

Which one would you choose? Is Icecap worth the extra $$? How much will bulb life be reduced by "overdriving" them?

Thanks for any input, Jamie

[RayAllen]

If i had to choose from the 2 id go with reefgeek, but im biast and love Icecap products.

[apedroza]

It also depends on what you plan on keeping. IF you want to do sps I would go with #2

[fjr_wertheimber]

I've got option #2, so well, I'm probably going to be biased in my answer.

[Jamie]

I'm wondering if the Workhorse will overdrive the bulbs at all. I mean...the Workhorse 7 on two bulbs vs. the Icecap 660 on three bulbs...hmmm. I know the Icecap is supposed to be the cat's meow...but is it that much more powerful? I just found a guy that will sell me three option #1 kits, as well as 6 bulbs, for $500 shipped. Then the stuff I already have can be reserved as spare parts just in case. I still haven't completely decided...but I'm leaning towards the Workhorse.

[Jamie]

fjr...how do you like the lights? How many bulbs are you running?

[Mr_Cool]

For t-5's, it has more to do with the reflectors than the ballasts. At least that's what I've read everywhere.

Actually, I just went back and looked at the links. I guess the reflectors are pretty equal there. Some swear by the Icecap, and others say TEK all the way.